HonestHomeCost
Topic

Garage Doors

Replacement, repair and springs, with the part price set against the bill it arrives in, and the published averages checked against each publisher's own tables.

This section opened on 12 November 2026. It works the way the rest of the site does: every figure names the guide it came from and the date that guide was updated, and where sources disagree we show the disagreement instead of splitting the difference.

One thing runs through all three pages here and is worth saying at the front. On a garage door, the part is a small share of the bill. A torsion spring is a hundred dollars of steel inside a job that costs three to five hundred, and the gap is labour, tension and risk. Every figure below makes more sense once you know which of the two you are looking at.

The questions so far

Page The short answer What it adds
Garage door replacement cost $993, $1,400 or $2,500 depending on the guide three averages from three different upstreams, and one guide prices a two-car door as exactly two one-car doors
Garage door repair cost $250 by one guide, $479 by the other a 92% gap between two averages, and a worked example from one of them showing parts at under a third of the bill
Garage door spring replacement cost $250 by two guides, $420 by the third the two that agree name different upstreams, and the one that differs names Homewyse
Garage door panel replacement cost $860 for one panel fitted the published average is that figure multiplied by two and a half, which is a number of panels nobody has

Where the numbers come from

Three publishers carry this section, and on this subject the attributions are unusually clear. Every This Old House page here names Homewyse, a pricing database, and the repair page adds Angi and names The Home Depot, Lowe's and Amazon for component prices. Bob Vila names Angi on the replacement page and HomeAdvisor, HomeServe and HomeGuide on the spring page. Fixr names pricing databases, licensed contractors and industry experts, and no individual publisher.

That matters because the disagreements here line up with the attributions rather than cutting across them. On springs, the Fixr and HomeAdvisor figures agree at $250 and the Homewyse figure is 68% higher. On new doors, all three differ and all three name something different. Either way it is more informative than the near-identical numbers we kept finding in our foundations section, where two publishers repeatedly turned out to be quoting one upstream dataset.

What connects this to the rest of the site

A garage is usually the one heated or half-heated space with a door the size of a wall, and the same questions about insulation and water reach it. If the garage floor is the problem rather than the door, our concrete slab page covers what that costs.

Questions answered