HonestHomeCost
Garage Doors

How much does garage door spring replacement cost?

Short answer

Fixr (updated January 31, 2025) puts spring replacement at $120 to $350 and says $250 is what the average homeowner pays for a broken torsion spring. Bob Vila (updated April 17, 2024) gives $150 to $350 with the same $250 average, from HomeAdvisor. This Old House (updated March 10, 2026) is the outlier at $300 to $540 with an average of $420, from Homewyse. Two of the three land on $250, so that is the figure to plan around, and the reason the job costs more than its part is in the This Old House table: a torsion spring itself is $80 to $120.

$200 to $350
Torsion spring replacement (Fixr)
$350 to $540
Torsion spring replacement, from Homewyse (This Old House)
$80 to $120
The torsion spring part itself (This Old House)
$250
Average spring replacement, from HomeAdvisor (Bob Vila)
$420
Average spring replacement, parts and professional labour (This Old House)

Two guides say $250. The third says $420.

Source Average Printed range Attributed to Updated
Fixr $250 for a broken torsion spring $120 to $350 not stated January 31, 2025
Bob Vila $250 $150 to $350 HomeAdvisor, HomeServe, HomeGuide April 17, 2024
This Old House $420 $300 to $540 Homewyse March 10, 2026

Our arithmetic, marked as ours. This Old House's average is $170 above the other two, which makes it 68.0% higher. Its range floor of $300 is below neither of theirs, but its ceiling of $540 is $190 above both.

Our reading, and it is worth being precise about what it does and does not show. Two independent guides landing on the same $250 is not proof that $250 is right, and we have spent this site documenting cases where identical figures turned out to be one dataset quoted twice. But here the two that agree name different upstreams, HomeAdvisor by way of Bob Vila and Fixr's own databases, while the one that differs names Homewyse. That is the opposite shape from the agreement-by-copying we found across our foundations section.

The practical answer: plan around $250 and treat $420 as the Homewyse figure, which is what This Old House's own footnote calls it. If your quote comes in near $500, it is at the top of one guide and off the end of two.

By type, the gap persists all the way down:

Spring type Fixr This Old House
Extension $120 to $250 $300 to $400
Torsion $200 to $350 $350 to $540

The two torsion bands meet at exactly $350, the top of one and the bottom of the other, and overlap nowhere else. The extension bands do not meet at all: Fixr's top of $250 is $50 below This Old House's floor of $300, which is our arithmetic. Bob Vila prices by what is included rather than by type, putting torsion at $75 to $150 to install including labour and materials and extension at $50 to $100 each, with a set of two springs at $60 to $150.

The part is a fifth of the bill

This Old House prices the spring and the job in the same table, which is what makes the whole subject legible.

Spring type Part only Installed
Extension $20 to $60 $300 to $400
Torsion $80 to $120 $350 to $540

Our arithmetic, marked as ours. Taking the cheapest end of each torsion column, the part is $80 of a $350 job, or 22.9%. At the dearest end it is $120 of $540, or 22.2%. An extension spring is a smaller share still.

Our reading. This is the number to carry away, because it explains every quote on this page and most of the suspicion people bring to them. You are not paying for steel. You are paying for someone to wind several hundred pounds of stored tension onto a shaft without being hurt, and to rebalance the door afterwards. Our repair page carries a worked example of exactly this job from the same publisher: $108 of parts, $192 of labour and a $60 service call, totalling $360.

This Old House is direct about the risk, and prices it: it notes that inexperienced contractors on complex spring work can create safety risks and larger repairs later.

Where spring work sits among the other repairs

Job Cost Source
Garage door tune-up $120 to $240 This Old House
Cable repair $170 to $320 This Old House
Repair and maintenance $190 to $350 This Old House
Opener replacement $430 to $730 This Old House
Panel replacement $440 to $725 This Old House
Automatic opener installation $500 to $860 This Old House
Bearings replacement $100 to $250 Fixr

Our reading. Springs sit in the middle of that list, below opener and panel work and above a tune-up. If a quote for spring work approaches the opener or panel figures, something else is being replaced at the same time, and it is worth asking what. Panel work in particular has the opposite cost structure to springs, with the part rather than the labour dominating, which our panel replacement page sets out.

Repair or replace the whole door

This Old House answers this directly on its spring page: spring replacement at $300 to $540 against $970 to $1,580 for a full garage door replacement, making spring repair the better choice when panels, tracks and opener are still functional.

One caution about that comparison, and it is ours. The same publisher's own garage door cost guide puts a new door at $1,151 to $1,869 with an average of $1,400. Both pages cite Homewyse. So the replacement figure used in the comparison is $181 lower at the bottom and $289 lower at the top than the figure the same publisher prints elsewhere, which is our arithmetic.

The conclusion survives either way, because $300 to $540 is well under both. But if you are weighing a borderline case, use the number from the page that is actually about new doors, which our replacement page sets against Fixr's.

How long a spring is supposed to last

Bob Vila is the only one of the three that gives a lifespan, and it gives it two ways.

Spring type Cycles Years
Torsion 10,000 to 20,000 8 to 15
Extension 8,000 to 15,000 7 to 12

It also prices maintenance against failure: a garage door tune-up costs $50 to $150, and once a spring breaks it cannot be repaired, only replaced. Cables, which work with the springs and back them up, run $75 to $200 alone, or $175 to $450 when replaced at the same time as a broken spring.

Our view, marked as ours. A cycle is one open and one close. A household that uses the door four times a day reaches 10,000 cycles in under seven years, which is why the year figures and the cycle figures describe the same springs rather than different ones. If yours is at that age, the second spring is near the end too, which is the practical argument for replacing the pair.

How to read a spring quote

Our view, marked as ours, drawn from the figures above.

  • Find out which spring you have. Torsion sits on a shaft above the door, extension runs along the tracks at the sides. The published bands differ by type.
  • Expect both springs to be replaced. Fixr notes that coils are virtually always replaced as a pair.
  • A quote near $250 matches two of the three guides. One supports up to $540.
  • Do not price it off the part. At $80 to $120 the spring is about a fifth of the job.
  • Ask whether two technicians are coming. Bob Vila notes that most companies send two for safety, and puts the service call at $75 to $150, attributed to HomeAdvisor.
  • Expect one to two hours. That is Bob Vila's figure for spring replacement.
  • Do not do it yourself to save the labour. That labour is the reason the job has a price.

What to take from this

  1. Two of three guides say $250. The third says $420 and is the one citing Homewyse.
  2. The part is around 22% of a torsion job at either end of the band.
  3. Springs are replaced in pairs, so price the pair.
  4. A torsion spring is good for 8 to 15 years, so age alone can answer the question.
  5. Replacing springs beats replacing the door while panels, tracks and opener are sound.

Sources

  1. This Old House, Garage Door Spring Replacement Cost (2026), updated March 10, 2026 (the $300 to $540 range and $420 average, the part and installed prices for extension and torsion springs, the related repair figures, the full replacement comparison figure, and the footnote attributing the data to Homewyse)
  2. Fixr, Garage Door Repair Cost, updated January 31, 2025 (the $120 to $350 spring and coil figures split by type, the $250 average for replacing a broken torsion spring, and the $150 to $350 overall repair range)
  3. This Old House, How Much Does a Garage Door Cost? (2026 Guide), updated March 13, 2026 (cited on this page only for the $1,151 to $1,869 replacement range, which differs from the replacement figure on the same publisher's spring page)
  4. This Old House, Garage Door Repair Cost (2026 Pricing), updated May 29, 2026 (cited on this page only for the worked spring repair example, $108 of parts, $192 of labour and a $60 service call totalling $360)
  5. Bob Vila, Garage Door Spring Replacement Cost Guide, updated April 17, 2024 (the $150 to $350 range and $250 average, the torsion and extension installed figures, the spring set price, the cycle and year lifespans, the labour rate attributed to HomeAdvisor, and the article source list naming HomeAdvisor, HomeServe and HomeGuide)

Price figures are national US ranges from the sources above as of the date shown. Your local price depends on labor rates, permits and site conditions. Read how we get our numbers.