The average is one panel multiplied
| What This Old House prices | Cost |
|---|---|
| Single panel replacement | $860 |
| Multiple panel replacement, 2 to 3 panels | $1,720 to $2,580 |
| Full set, single car door | $3,440 |
| Printed average | $2,150 |
| Printed range | $860 to $3,440 |
Our arithmetic, marked as ours, and it accounts for the whole table. Every figure above is the single panel price multiplied: $860 by two is $1,720, by three is $2,580, by four is $3,440. The printed average of $2,150 is $860 by two and a half.
Our reading. Nobody replaces two and a half panels. The $2,150 average answers no question a homeowner has, because the question is always how many panels are damaged, and that is one, or it is the whole door. The usable figure on the page is $860 for one, and that is also the figure Fixr's band brackets.
We have found the same construction repeatedly, most recently on our garage door replacement page, where a two-car door was priced as exactly two one-car doors.
What a real one looked like
This Old House publishes a worked example, which is more use than its average.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Steel panel | $778 |
| Labour | $95 |
| Total | $873 |
Our arithmetic, marked as ours. Labour is 10.9% of that bill.
Our reading, and it is the opposite of the pattern next door. On our spring replacement page the part is about a fifth of the job and the labour is the dangerous part. Here it inverts: the panel is almost the entire cost and the fitting is an hour of straightforward work. The same trade, two jobs, opposite cost structures. So the question to ask changes too. For springs, ask who is doing it. For panels, ask what the panel costs.
This Old House puts panel work at around $63 per hour, with a single section swap taking 1 to 2 hours.
The two publishers are far apart on one panel
| Figure | Cost | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Single panel replaced | $860 | This Old House |
| Panel and window replacement | $150 to $1,000 | Fixr |
| Panel repair rather than replacement | $150 to $500 | Fixr |
| Bent door, repair or panel | $100 to $700 | Fixr |
| Aluminium door repairs | $200 to $600 | Fixr |
| Basic steel panels, part only | $500 to $900 | This Old House |
Our reading. This Old House's single panel figure of $860 sits just under the top of Fixr's whole replacement band. The part explains it: This Old House prices a basic steel panel at $500 to $900 before labour, so an $860 total is a mid-range panel fitted. Fixr's $150 end is a different job, nearer its own panel repair figure, and Fixr says so plainly: a dent or crack may be patched rather than replaced.
So before pricing anything, establish whether the panel is being repaired or replaced. That is a difference of several hundred dollars and both publishers treat it as a separate decision.
What gets added to the bill
All This Old House figures: disposing of old sections averages $370, which some contractors include. Rush or emergency service adds $100 to $250. A track adjustment, frame repair or spring rebalancing alongside the panel runs $147 to $300. Insulated steel panels cost 10% to 20% more than basic steel.
It also notes what you can do for nothing: small dents in steel often pop out with heat and gentle pressure, and surface scratches take touch-up paint at $3 to $8 per can. Once a panel cracks, warps or holes, it says a new panel is the better option.
Our view, marked as ours. The disposal fee is the one to ask about, because at $370 it is close to half the cost of the panel itself and it is sometimes bundled and sometimes not.
When a panel is no longer the answer
If the full set is the plan, you are no longer comparing against panels. This Old House's own full-set figure of $3,440 for a single car door is above every new-door average we have on our replacement page, and a new door arrives with new tracks, hardware and warranty rather than old ones.
If the door works but one component does not, our repair page covers the rest of the list.
What to take from this
- $860 is the number, for one panel, fitted.
- $2,150 is $860 times two and a half. Ignore it.
- $873 is what a real one cost, of which only $95 was labour.
- Repair or replace is the first question. Fixr puts a patch at $150 to $500.
- A full set at $3,440 is a new door conversation, not a repair.
Sources
- This Old House, Garage Door Panel Replacement Cost (2026 Price Guide), updated April 16, 2026 (the $860 single panel figure, the $2,150 average and $860 to $3,440 range, the tier table, the steel panel and hourly figures, the disposal, rush and adjustment costs, and the worked single panel example)
- Fixr, Garage Door Repair Cost, updated January 31, 2025 (the $150 to $1,000 panel and window replacement figure, the $150 to $500 panel repair figure, the $100 to $700 bent door figure, and the aluminium and steel repair ranges)
Price figures are national US ranges from the sources above as of the date shown. Your local price depends on labor rates, permits and site conditions. Read how we get our numbers.