HonestHomeCost
Topic

Insulation

Spray foam, blown-in and attic work, priced by the square foot, with every published total checked against the rate it was built from.

This section opened on 15 November 2026. It works the way the rest of the site does: every figure names the guide it came from and the date that guide was updated, and where sources disagree we show the disagreement instead of splitting the difference.

One thing runs through all three pages and is worth saying at the front. Insulation is sold by the square foot, and almost every published total is that rate multiplied by an area somebody else assumed. Once you know your own area and your material, the totals stop being useful and the rate starts being enough.

The questions so far

Page The short answer What it adds
Spray foam insulation cost $1 to $4.50 per square foot by one guide, $3.15 to $7.50 by the other the clearest borrowed-numbers case we have found: one guide names the other, and its worked house figures are the other's four rates times 1,500, to the dollar
Attic insulation cost $0.30 to $12 per square foot depending on the material a 40-fold spread inside one job, plus the removal cost that published rates leave out
Blown-in insulation cost $0.50 to $2.30 per square foot the same publisher prints two different rates for this material on two of its own pages, and its material table shows which is which
Crawl space insulation cost $2,000 to insulate, $5,500 to encapsulate two different jobs routinely quoted as one, and the vapor barrier is what tells them apart

What we found doing this

The provenance question got a clean answer here. Across this site we keep finding two guides printing figures that trace to one upstream, and usually the best we can do is note the coincidence. On the spray foam page we could do better: This Old House states in a footnote that its data comes from HomeGuide, HomeAdvisor and Fixr, and its worked figures for a 1,500 square foot house reproduce Fixr's four per-square-foot rates multiplied by 1,500 exactly, four times out of four. That is not a resemblance, it is a derivation.

And the multiplication habit is everywhere in this subject. Fixr's blown-in area table is its rate times the area in every row, with no quantity discount. This Old House's spray foam area table is the same for two rows out of three, and the third row does not follow its own headline rate. We say so on each page, because a table built that way looks like evidence and is not.

Where the numbers come from

Three publishers carry this section. This Old House names its upstream on every page it supplies here, HomeGuide, HomeAdvisor and Fixr on spray foam, and contractor estimates used by Angi on the attic page. Bob Vila names Angi and HomeAdvisor on spray foam and lists HomeAdvisor, Angi, HomeGuide and Fixr as its article sources. Fixr names pricing databases, licensed contractors and industry experts, and no individual publisher.

That makes one comparison on the blown-in page worth more than it looks: where the Angi-derived This Old House figure and Fixr's general page agree closely by different routes, and Fixr's own dedicated page sits above both, the two that agree are the better guide.

What connects this to the rest of the site

Insulation and moisture are the same conversation from two directions. Our foundations section covers water reaching a crawl space or basement, which is where insulation most often fails, and our heating and cooling section covers the equipment whose running cost insulation is meant to reduce.

Questions answered