Four rows out of five are the same number
Both guides price pumping by the size of the tank. Put the two tables side by side.
| Tank size | Fixr, updated January 31, 2025 | This Old House, updated May 22, 2026 | Same? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 750 gallons | $175 to $300 | $175 to $300 | identical |
| 1,000 gallons | $225 to $400 | $225 to $400 | identical |
| 1,250 gallons | $300 to $600 | $275 to $500 | differs |
| 1,500 gallons | $345 to $600 | $345 to $600 | identical |
| 1,750 gallons | $400 to $700 | $400 to $700 | identical |
Four of the five rows agree to the dollar at both ends. That is eight endpoints in a row with no daylight between them.
This Old House says where its table came from. Under it the page prints: "Cost data was sourced from Angi." Fixr says only that it gathers figures from pricing databases, licensed contractors and industry experts, and names no individual publisher.
So this is not two guides arriving at the same prices independently. It is one set of figures showing up twice, and one of the two tells you so.
The one row they disagree on is the one most people need
The exception is the 1,250 gallon row. Fixr prints $300 to $600, This Old House prints $275 to $500.
Our arithmetic, marked as ours. Fixr's ceiling is $100 above the other, which is 1.2 times it. Fixr's floor is $25 above, which is about 1.09 times it.
Now the part that matters. Fixr writes that 1,250 gallons is "the most common size for a septic tank in the U.S." Of the five rows, the only one where the two guides part company is the size most readers actually have.
There is a second thing in that row. Fixr's headline range for the whole subject is $300 to $600, and its 1,250 gallon row is $300 to $600. The same two numbers. Our reading, marked as ours: Fixr's national range is not an average over all tank sizes, it is the row for the common size, used as the headline. That is a defensible way to build a headline, and it is worth knowing, because it means the number does not describe your tank unless your tank is that size.
This Old House prints four different pumping ranges on four of its own pages
This is the stranger finding, and it is all within one publisher.
| Where | What it prints | Updated |
|---|---|---|
| The pumping guide | $290 to $560, average $420 | May 22, 2026 |
| The septic tank overview | $289 to $555 | June 10, 2026 |
| The installation guide, maintenance section | $300 to $600 | March 12, 2026 |
| Its own table on the pumping guide | $175 to $700 across five sizes | May 22, 2026 |
Our arithmetic, marked as ours. The first two are $1 apart at the floor and $5 apart at the ceiling. Numbers that close are not two estimates; they are one estimate, rounded twice.
The third is the interesting one. $300 to $600 is exactly Fixr's headline range, printed inside a This Old House page. We cannot show how it got there, and we are not claiming we can. We can say that four of these publishers' five table rows already match, and that the one range This Old House prints outside its own table is the other publisher's headline.
The headline does not come out of the table
This Old House prints $420 as the average and $290 to $560 as the range. Its own table is right there on the same page, so we checked whether one produces the other.
Our arithmetic, marked as ours.
- The midpoints of the five rows are $237.50, $312.50, $387.50, $472.50 and $550. Their mean is $392, which is $28 below the printed average of $420.
- The mean of the five floors is $284, against a printed floor of $290.
- The mean of the five ceilings is $500, against a printed ceiling of $560.
So the headline is near the table at the bottom and well away from it at the top. It is not the average of the rows.
More useful for a reader: the page says most 1,000 gallon tanks serve a family of four, and Fixr says 1,250 gallons is the most common size. Our arithmetic again: the printed floor of $290 sits $65 above the 1,000 gallon row's floor of $225 and $15 above the 1,250 gallon row's floor of $275. If you have an ordinary tank, the cheapest plausible price is below the number at the top of the page.
How often, and what else lands on the bill
The interval is where the two guides genuinely agree, and both tie it to size.
| Fixr | This Old House | |
|---|---|---|
| 750 gallons | every 2 to 5 years, for a 1 to 2 bedroom home | every 2 to 3 years |
| 1,000 gallons | every 3 to 5 years, for a 2 to 3 bedroom home | every 3 to 5 years for a family of four |
| 1,250 gallons | every 3 to 5 years, for a 3 to 5 bedroom home | not stated separately |
| 1,500 gallons | every 3 to 5 years, for a 5 to 7 bedroom home | may go 4 to 5 years |
This Old House also prices the things that get added at the same visit:
- Camera inspection: $250 to $500
- Filter cleaning: $100 to $1,000
- Bacteria additive treatment: $300 to $600
- Line snaking for clogs: $1,500 to $1,900
Note the last one. A clog found during a pump-out can cost more than three pump-outs. Fixr puts a one-time inspection, booked separately rather than during a cleaning, at $100 to $300, and says that if repairs follow, the inspection cost generally rolls into the repair cost.
How to read a pumping quote
Our view, marked as ours, drawn from the figures above.
- Ask the tank size before you compare anything. Both guides price by size, and the spread from 750 to 1,750 gallons is $175 to $700 in Fixr's table. A quote without a size attached cannot be checked.
- If your tank is 1,250 gallons, expect the two guides to disagree. $275 to $500 and $300 to $600 are the published figures. That is the one size where they do.
- Do not treat $420 or $400 as your price. Neither comes out of the size table, and your tank is a size.
- Ask whether a filter clean is included. At $100 to $1,000 it is the widest add-on on either page.
- Treat a snaking charge as a separate decision. $1,500 to $1,900 is a repair, not maintenance.
- If the visit turns up a problem, price the check separately. Our septic inspection page sets out which of four different jobs the word covers, and our installation page covers what a replacement system costs.
What to take from this
- Four of five rows in the two tables are identical to the dollar, and This Old House names Angi as the source of its table.
- The single row where they differ is 1,250 gallons, which Fixr calls the most common size in the US.
- Fixr's headline range is its 1,250 gallon row, not an average across sizes.
- This Old House prints $290 to $560, $289 to $555 and $300 to $600 on three of its own pages, and the third is the other publisher's headline.
- The printed floors sit above the table's floors, so an ordinary tank can cost less than the page's minimum.
Sources
- Fixr, Septic Tank Cleaning Cost, updated January 31, 2025 (the $300 to $600 range and $400 national average, the table of cleaning cost by tank size from 750 to 1,750 gallons, the statement that 1,250 gallons is the most common size in the US, the $175 to $700 span across sizes, the cleaning frequency table by number of bedrooms, the one-time inspection figure and the RV figures)
- This Old House, What Is the Cost to Pump a Septic Tank?, updated May 22, 2026 (the $420 average and $290 to $560 range, the pumping cost table by tank size with its footnote naming Angi, the pumping intervals by tank size, the camera inspection, filter cleaning, bacteria additive and line snaking figures, and the three year inspection figure)
- This Old House, Septic Tanks: A Comprehensive Guide for Homeowners, updated June 10, 2026 (the $289 to $555 regular pumping figure, the $630 to $3,033 repair figure and the roughly $550 inspection figure, used here only to show that the same publisher prints a third pumping range on a third page)
- This Old House, How Much Does a Septic Tank Installation Cost?, updated March 12, 2026 (the $300 to $600 pumping figure given in its maintenance section, used here only to show that the same publisher prints a fourth pumping range on a fourth page)
Price figures are national US ranges from the sources above as of the date shown. Your local price depends on labor rates, permits and site conditions. Read how we get our numbers.