The decision in one table
Replacement is the cheap half of this subject, and the numbers show why clearly enough that you can make the call yourself.
| Item | Cost | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Replace the pump in an existing basin, fitted | $350 to $1,000 | This Old House |
| Repair, typical | $150 to $500 | Fixr |
| Repair, average | $300 | Fixr |
| Replace the motor | $250 to $500 | Fixr |
| Replace the battery | $250 to $500 | Fixr |
| Replace the discharge pipe | $175 to $600 | Fixr |
| Replace the impeller | $125 to $250 | Fixr |
| Replace the check valve | $125 to $200 | Fixr |
| Replace the float switch | $100 to $150 | Fixr |
| Pedestal pump, unit only | $60 to $170 | Bob Vila |
| Submersible pump, unit only | $100 to $400 | Bob Vila |
Our reading, marked as ours, and it is the whole point of the page. Fixr's motor at $250 to $500 is its single dearest part, and it costs more than Bob Vila's dearest submersible unit at $400. A float switch or a check valve is worth fixing. A motor usually is not, because for roughly the same money the whole pump is new and the clock starts again.
The cheap repairs are cheap for a reason: Fixr's low case is $75 to fix a faulty float switch, and its high case is $600 to replace a large amount of discharge piping, which is pipework rather than pump.
Replacement is not installation, and the gap is large
This is the figure people arrive looking for and often find the wrong version of.
| Job | Cost | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement in an existing basin | $350 to $1,000 | This Old House |
| New installation, average | $1,400 | This Old House |
| New installation, average | $1,500 | Bob Vila |
| New installation in a concrete floor | $2,500 to $5,000 | Bob Vila |
Our arithmetic, marked as ours. The top of the replacement band, $1,000, is $400 below This Old House's average for a new installation and $500 below Bob Vila's.
The reason is labour, and both guides say it directly. Bob Vila puts labour at $45 to $200 per hour and says a replacement usually takes around an hour, against 2 to 4 hours for a new installation. The basin, the hole and the drainage already exist, so what is left is unplumbing one pump and plumbing in another.
Our sump pump installation page covers the new-installation case, including why This Old House's printed range for it is Fixr's best and worst case rather than a typical band.
When the pump is simply old
Bob Vila gives the lifespans, and they differ by design in a way most buyers do not expect.
| Type | Typical lifespan | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Pedestal | 20 to 25 years | Bob Vila |
| Submersible | 5 to 15 years | Bob Vila |
It adds that some higher-quality submersibles last 10 to 30 years. This Old House, on its own page, gives a pedestal up to 30 years and a submersible 5 to 15 years.
Our reading, marked as ours. The submersible is the quieter, more powerful and more common choice, and it is also the one that will be replaced two or three times in the life of one pedestal. That is not an argument against it. It is an argument for treating replacement as scheduled maintenance rather than as a failure, and for knowing that the $350 to $1,000 will come round again.
Bob Vila also puts maintenance at up to $250 a year for checks, which over a submersible's life is a meaningful share of what a new pump costs.
How to decide
Our view, marked as ours, drawn from the figures above.
- Find out which part failed before agreeing to anything. The parts list above spans $100 to $600, and the answer decides everything.
- A float switch, valve or impeller is a repair. All three are under $250 at the top.
- A motor is a replacement. At $250 to $500 it costs about what a new pump fitted into the existing basin costs at the bottom of its band.
- Ask whether the basin and discharge are being reused. If they are, you are in the $350 to $1,000 job, not the $1,400 one.
- Count the pump's age. Past ten years, a submersible is inside its replacement window whatever the symptom is.
If the pump is running constantly rather than failing, the problem is upstream of it: that is a drainage question, covered on our French drain page, or a waterproofing one, on our basement waterproofing page.
What to take from this
- $350 to $1,000 replaces a pump in an existing basin, fitted.
- $300 is the average repair, and the repair band tops out at $500.
- The motor is the tipping point. At $250 to $500 it is not worth replacing inside an old pump.
- Replacement is about an hour, against 2 to 4 for a new installation, which is where the price difference lives.
- Submersibles last 5 to 15 years. Budget for the next one rather than being surprised by it.
Sources
- This Old House, How Much Does Sump Pump Installation Cost? (2026), updated March 11, 2026 (the $350 to $1,000 replacement figure, the $1,400 average and $500 to $4,000 range for new installation, and the footnote attributing the data to Fixr and Angi)
- Fixr, Sump Pump Repair Cost, updated January 31, 2025 (the $150 to $500 repair range and $300 average, the $75 low case and $600 high case, and the replacement part prices for float switch, valve, impeller, discharge pipe, battery and motor)
- Bob Vila, Budget Breakdown, How Much a Sump Pump Typically Costs to Install, updated January 12, 2024 (the $1,200 to $2,500 range and $1,500 average attributed to Angi, the $200 to $500 repair figure, the pedestal and submersible unit prices and lifespans, and the labour rate and replacement duration)
Price figures are national US ranges from the sources above as of the date shown. Your local price depends on labor rates, permits and site conditions. Read how we get our numbers.